How to Eliminate Decision Fatigue

Uncategorized

Blog Cover Image with a photo of a woman looking into her wardrobe and looking confused

You open your closet. It’s packed with clothes- some with tags still on, some you haven’t worn in years, and a few faithful pieces you reach for constantly because they’re “safe.”

You stand there, already exhausted, thinking: “I have nothing to wear.”

Sound familiar?

This isn’t a wardrobe problem. This is decision fatigue masquerading as a closet full of clothes.

What usually happens next: You go shopping, buy another black top or pair of jeans that’s almost identical to what you already own, and the cycle continues. You’re not building a wardrobe- you’re collecting safety nets.

As a personal stylist, I see this pattern all the time. People who make complex decisions all day long get to their closet and completely freeze. Their wardrobe doesn’t support their actual life (hence, the need to make a million micro decisions in order to get dressed). 

If you’re looking for closet clean out tips or are looking for help to have cohesive wardrobe styling, the solution is not buying more storage containers or following generic fashion tips. It’s time to create a system that actually reflects your personal style and eliminates the overwhelm.

WHAT IS DECISION FATIGUE (AND WHY YOUR CLOSET IS MAKING IT WORSE)

woman looking at her closet and not knowing what to wear, experiencing wardrobe fatigue

Decision fatigue is the mental exhaustion and deteriorating quality of decisions which occur after a long period of making numerous choices. By the time you’re staring at your closet in the morning, you’ve already made dozens of micro-decisions: when to wake up, what to eat, how to start your day, taking care of your pet, etc. 

Your brain is tired. And a disorganized closet full of clothes that don’t work together? That’s asking your exhausted brain to solve a complex puzzle before you’ve even had a cup of coffee.

The result? You default to the same “safe” pieces over and over. Not because you love them, but because choosing them requires zero mental energy.

THE REAL PROBLEM: YOUR CLOSET ISN’T ALIGNED WITH YOUR LIFE

You don’t need more storage solutions or prettier hangers. You need a wardrobe that reflects who you actually are and how you actually live.

When clients come to me stuck in this cycle, they usually experience one (or more) of the following:

1. Clothes from different life chapters living together

That corporate blazer from your office job five years ago? The “going out” top from when you went out to clubs 10 years ago? The jeans from when you were a completely different size? They’re all taking up space and mental energy, even though they no longer serve your current life.

2. No clear understanding of their personal style

Without knowing what actually makes you feel confident and authentic, every shopping trip becomes a guessing game. You buy what’s on trend or what worked for someone else, not what works for you. 

3. A wardrobe built on “shoulds” instead of reality

You keep that dress because you think you should attend more fancy events. You bought those heels because you feel like you should dress up more. But your actual life involves school drop-offs, Zoom calls, and maybe one fancy dinner a month.

4. Everything is the same, safe neutral

Black. Gray. Navy. Repeat. You’ve defaulted to neutrals so entirely that getting dressed feels monotonous, but stepping outside of that feels terrifying because you don’t know what actually works on you (or what you like). 

HOW TO ELIMINATE DECISION FATIGUE FROM YOUR WARDROBE

a person going through their wardrobe and doing an honest audit of what to keep and what to eliminate, to reduce wardrobe overwhelm

This isn’t about clearing out your entire closet in a weekend. This is about creating a strategic system that makes getting dressed feel effortless (and maybe even fun).

Step 1: The Honest Audit

Most closet clean out tips start with: “If you haven’t worn it in a year, toss it!” But that’s too generic (and isn’t getting to the root issue).

Instead, ask yourself these questions about each piece:

  1. Does this fit my body right now? Not your goal body. Not your past body. Your current, beautiful, deserving-of-great-clothes body.
  2. Does this reflect who I am now? Not who you were five years ago or who you think you should be. Who you actually are today.
  3. Does this work for my current life chapter? Not the life you imagine having. The life you’re actually living- with Zoom calls, IRL client meetings, coffee dates, concerts with friends, and the occasional fancy event.
  4. Do I feel good when I wear this? Not “it’s fine” or “it’ll do.” Actually good. Confident. Like yourself.

If the answer to any of these is no, it’s time to release it. A no, but with gratitude for what it served, and clarity about what you need now.

Step 2: Identify Your Style Anchors (The Pieces You Actually Wear)

Look at what you reach for constantly. What are the common threads?

Maybe you love:

  • Structured pieces that make you feel put-together
  • Soft, flowing fabrics that feel comfortable
  • Bold colors that make you feel vibrant
  • Classic silhouettes that feel timeless
  • Statement pieces that spark conversations

These are your anchors- the foundation of your authentic personal style. Everything else in your closet should complement these pieces. (One of my favorite style tips!)

This is where color analysis becomes powerful. When you know your color season, you can identify which of your go-to pieces actually make you glow and which are washing you out. Suddenly, it’s not about having 15 black tops- it’s about having 3 tops in colors that make you radiant. (Don’t know your color season? Take my free quiz to find yours!)

Step 3: Create a Capsule Mindset (Not a Capsule Wardrobe)

I’m not asking you to own only 15 pieces. But adopting a capsule mindset changes everything.

This means:

  • Every piece works with at least 3 other pieces in your closet. If you can only wear that top with one specific pair of pants, it’s creating more work, not less.
  • Your wardrobe has a cohesive color story. This doesn’t mean everything is beige. Rather, your colors work together in harmony. When you know your color season, this becomes exponentially easier (and it’s fun to mix and match).
  • Invest in quality basics, have fun with statement pieces. Your everyday jeans, well-fitting bras, and classic tops? Worth investing in. Trendy pieces? Buy them if you love them, but don’t expect them to be wardrobe staples.

Leave room for evolution
Your style is meant to evolve as you do. A capsule mindset means regularly editing, making sure your wardrobe is supporting your current life chapter, and what you’re drawn to. 

Step 4: Shop With Intention

This is where the “buying the same pieces over and over” cycle breaks.

Before you buy anything new, ask:

  1. What gap is this filling in my wardrobe? If the answer is “I don’t know, I just liked it,” that’s a sign to pause. If you can’t immediately envision 3+ outfits with it- let’s take a step back and rethink that purchase.

  2. Does this align with my color season and personal style? If you’re a Spring wearing muted olive green because it’s trendy, you’re possibly setting yourself up for another unworn piece taking up space. Remember, we want a wardrobe that works together instead of pieces that feel disjointed and not confidently representing who you are.

  3. Am I buying this because it’s safe, or because I genuinely love it? There’s a difference between “this is fine and won’t make me stand out” and “this makes me feel incredible.” Time to choose the latter, babe.

  4. Is this for my actual life or my imaginary one? That sequined top for “someday when I go out more”? Unless you have a specific event on the calendar, leave it at the store (or in the cart if you love to shop online like me).

YOUR SECRET WEAPON: COLOR ANALYSIS 

three women with their personal color palettes as part of their color analysis

Knowing your colors is your styling BFF.

When you understand your color season, shopping and getting dressed becomes exponentially more joyful because:

  • You eliminate an entire series of decisions. That gorgeous coral dress? Maybe not for you if you’re a Summer. That olive jacket? Possibly skip it if you’re a Spring. You’re not shopping in the entire store anymore– you’re shopping in your colors. This decreases the amount of decisions you make, calling back more of your energy.

  • You can borrow from trends selectively. You don’t have to sit trends out entirely (they are such a fun way to experiment!). You just need to find your version of that trend. Everyone’s wearing red? Cool- a True Winter wears a blue-based red, while a Spring rocks an orange-based coral-red.

  • Your closet naturally coordinates. When all your clothes are in colors that suit you and work together, getting dressed becomes like playing with a perfectly curated paint palette instead of trying to force mismatched colors to cooperate.

  • You stop buying duplicates out of desperation. You’re not grabbing another black top hoping this one will finally work. You know exactly which colors make you glow, so you buy with confidence.

BUILDING A WARDROBE THAT WORKS: YOUR PERSONAL CHECKLIST

Step 1: The Purge
Set aside a few hours. Try everything on. Be ruthlessly honest about what fits your current body, life, and style. Create three piles: Keep, Donate, and Maybe (revisit the Maybe pile after a hot minute- aka a week or two).

Step 2: The Assessment
Look at what you kept. What are your style anchors? What’s missing? Are there any gaps? Don’t rush out shopping yet- we are only observing here. 

Step 3: The Color Analysis
Take my free Color Analysis Quiz (or book a 1:1 session with me). Understanding your season will completely shift how you see your wardrobe and how you shop going forward.

Step 4: The Strategic Shopping List
Based on your gaps and your colors, create a specific list. Not something basic like “new jeans”- but “dark wash straight-leg jeans in my best true blue-toned denim.” Specificity prevents impulse buying.

Ongoing: The Seasonal Edit
Every few months, do a quick edit. What’s no longer serving you? What needs to be replaced? What do you want to incorporate or invite in? This prevents the closet decision overwhelm from building back up.

READY TO ELIMINATE DECISION FATIGUE FOR GOOD?

Susan Padron completing a 1:1 in-person color analysis session

Start with my Free Color Analysis Quiz to discover your color season. Once you know your colors, everything else- the closet edit, the shopping, the getting dressed- becomes infinitely smoother.

And if you’re ready for a complete transformation? My styling packages range from 3-month to 12-month programs that include wardrobe audits, personalized shopping (virtual or in-person), and ongoing support as you build a wardrobe that actually works for you and your life.

Because you deserve to open your closet and feel excited, not exhausted.
You deserve clothes that make you feel like your best self.

P.S. Want more personalized style guidance and personal styling support? Check out my styling packages or tune in to my podcast on Apple or Spotify where we talk all things style, confidence, and authenticity!

view masterclasses

If you’re not yet ready to invest in a long partnership, but still want to pursue building your own authentic style, then check out my two best-selling masterclasses today. 

ON-DEMAND STYLE
MASTERCLASSES

FEELING READY TO LEARN AT YOUR OWN PACE?

PRESS & MEDIA INQUIRIES

PERSONAL STYLING.

STYLE Translation. 

CONFIDENCE BUILDING.

Guiding Change with